To my (and my partner’s, friends’ and family’s) great surprise, I’m the opposite kind of parent. My almost two-year-old daughter is a tiny scrap of a thing, with a sweet temperament, healthy constitution and a tendency to be cautious.
As a result – knock on wood here – we haven’t yet been faced with emergency hospital runs or any serious health problems, a surprise considering the circumstances of her birth (she was in NICU due to being born in the 1st percentile).
Loading
Now, I have wholeheartedly embraced the mantra of laissez faire parenting, perhaps as a direct response to my own kind, but rather strict, upbringing.
The daughter of migrants, I was not allowed to go to sleepovers of friends who weren’t family friends. Despite an unblemished high school record and fairly responsible teenage behaviour, my parents felt uncomfortable sending me to schoolies (just a small house on the Victorian coast with a group of female friends), which I saw as unnecessarily strict and intrusive, especially as I was 18 at the time.
Their strictness has resulted in an unexpected twist: a wholehearted belief that I should not interfere too much in my child’s actions, and to take the rather relaxed approach of “she’ll be right” if something does go wrong. Looking back, this approach was the source of the recent friction between my friend and me.
“We don’t understand our own values and perspectives behind parenting until we’re actually doing it.”
Jayne Ferguson, clinician and centre manager at Relationships Australia Victoria
She – who had grown up in similar circumstances to mine – carries the weight of multiple miscarriages, and becomes distressed when she perceives any hurt befalling her child (or any child, really). Having experienced tragedy has primed her to be extra cautious – something I didn’t quite understand until that day.
There’s no ‘right’ way to parent
“It’s really important to recognise there are many different and widely varying parenting styles, and that what you do as a parent depends on what you’ve experienced yourself, what your partner – if there is one – experienced, and what you have rejected in your own life,” says Jayashri Kulkarni, professor of psychiatry at Alfred Health and Monash University.
“Add to that media influences, and the opinions of grandparents, extended family and friends, and it can leave all of us confused.”
As any parent will know, the act of parenting is a minefield, laden with our own childhood experiences, external and internal judgments and reactions to them. Everyone has their own ideas of what constitutes being a good mother or father, and the reasons behind these are complex.
Ferguson says that, besides being one of the most significant changes to happen to us, having children can be that catalyst for behaviour and responses we never imagined in ourselves.
“We don’t understand our own values and perspectives behind parenting until we’re actually doing it. And when we are challenged, we’re drawn to think about where we come from,” she says. “In many ways, we see being a parent as a way of redoing our own childhood. It’s almost like nature gives us a second chance to fix things for our own child.”
These “unspoken concerns”, which we often don’t even know we have, can arise in stressful situations, spilling over and impacting relationships not just with friends but also with family and other loved ones, Kulkrani says.
Getting over parenting differences
Loading
The trick to overcoming drastically different responses to child raising is communication, both experts agree.
“As long as lines of communications are kept open, and there’s honest expression without being hurtful, people can get past vastly different parenting approaches,” Kulkarni says.
Ferguson adds: “People get reluctant to talk honestly because they think they’re having a go at their friend, but it’s actually about having an open discussion and being open to self-reflection.”
This type of conflict also calls into question the investment we want to make in our friendships, and whether we are willing to persevere despite the differences.
“The children aren’t going anywhere – maybe it’s time to assess whether this friendship should continue without the children at this stage,” Ferguson says. “It can also be the case that there’s a distance for a period and after that, you come back together.”
As with most complex issues, there is no right answer. Ferguson warns some friendships may never recover, while others will remain changed.
“Intuition about what your child needs is critical, and so is self-reflection about how you parent,” she says. “Parenting is a learning and sharing experience, and it’s important to not assume anything about how other people do things.”
Thankfully, my friend and I have been able to get to a place where we are talking regularly. I wrote this article with her input and permission: it’s not only been part of the process of our recovery, but an issue we both wanted to raise more widely.
After all, our kids aren’t going anywhere – and I don’t think we are, either.
Make the most of your health, relationships, fitness and nutrition with our Live Well newsletter. Get it in your inbox every Monday.
